Billy Eichner
Bobby
Luke Macfarlane
Aaron
Guy Branum
Henry
Miss Lawrence
Wanda
Ts Madison
Angela
Dot-Marie Jones
Cherry
Jim Rash
Robert
Eve Lindley
Tamara
Monica Raymund
Tina
Guillermo Díaz
Edgar
Jai Rodriguez
Jason
Amanda Bearse
Anne
Debra Messing
Debra Messing
Peter Y. Kim
Peter
Justin Covington
Paul
Symone
Marty
Ryan Faucett
Josh
Becca Blackwell
Lucas
D'Lo
Tom
Harvey Fierstein
Louis
Bowen Yang
Lawrence Grape
Dahlia Rodriguez
Hannah
Derrick Delgado
Brian
George Dvorsky
Bruce
Jamyl Dobson
Joel
Brock Ciarlelli
Steve
Kenan Thompson
James Baldwin
Amy Schumer
Eleanor Roosevelt
Jillian Gottlieb
Samantha
Rick Crom
Grape's Neighbor
Everett Quinton
Melvin Funk
Thomas Vorsteg
Polyamorous Man
Julia Scotti
Straight Older Woman
Feliziano Flores
Rowdy Bear
Allison Reese
Aaron's Assistant
Gara Lonning
Receptionist
Nanie Méndez
Party Guest
Eileen Noonan
Party Guest
Courtney Chu
Teenage Girl
Ryan Daly
Grindr Guy
Brayden Morgan
Judgey Boy
William Popp
Pride Awards Football Player
Aidan Wharton
Football Player
Jovan E'Sean
Football Player
Joey Taranto
Singing Waiter
Courtney Bassett
Singing Waiter
Joshua L.K. Patterson
Singing Waiter
Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth
Edythe Jason
Paul's Grandma
Lorenzo Scott
Paul's Grandpa
Keith Milkie
Baseball Player
Alex Ringler
Baseball Player's Man
Cedric Leiba, Jr.
Harness Guy
Clayton Paterson
Hot Santa
Legendary Monster Babylon
Vogueing Man
Doug Trapp
Movie Exec
Jesús Martínez Jr.
Drag Queen
Daren J. Fleming
Drag Queen
Shannon O'Neill
Paula
Matthew Wilkas
Handsome Grindr Guy
Charles J. Roby
Wealthy Benefactor
Ben Stiller
Ben Stiller (uncredited)
Seth Meyers
Harvey Milk (uncredited)
Anthony DeVito
Straight Liberal Dad (uncredited)
Joanne Lamstein
Straight Liberal Mom (uncredited)