Seth Rogen
Andy Brewster
Barbra Streisand
Joyce Brewster
Yvonne Strahovski
Jessica
Colin Hanks
Rob
Brett Cullen
Ben
Adam Scott
Andrew Margolis Jr.
Ari Graynor
Joyce Margolis
Kathy Najimy
Gayle
Danny Pudi
Sanjay
Casey Wilson
Amanda
Dale Dickey
Tammy
Brandon Keener
Ryan Mcfee
Robert Curtis Brown
Bob Ferguson
Nora Dunn
Amy
Miriam Margolyes
Anita
Rose Abdoo
Diana
Analeis Anderson
Moonlight
Gabrielle Gumbs
Stripper
Rick Gonzalez
Mark
Worth Howe
Bob
Vicki Goldsmith
Young Joyce
Constance Esposito
HSN Executive
Creed Bratton
Suitor
Jeff Kober
Jimmy
Tom Virtue
Mature Singles Man
John Funk
K-Mart Executive
Julene Renee
K-Mart Receptionist (as Julene Renee-Preciado)
Matthew Levinson
Toddler Andy
Vivian Vanderwerd
Mature Singles Woman
Zabryna Guevara
K-Mart Executive
Michael Cassidy
Fake Andy (uncredited)